Highest and best use, explained

Highest and best use is how real estate professionals decide what a piece of land should become. It is also where HABU's name comes from.

Definition

The most valuable use a site can realistically support

The Appraisal Institute defines highest and best use as "the reasonably probable and legal use of vacant land or an improved property that is physically possible, legally permissible, appropriately supported, financially feasible, and that results in the highest value."

In plain words: of every use a site could legally and physically hold, it is the one that makes economic sense and creates the most value.

The four tests

Highest And Best Use is a foundational concept in urban economics and land planning. It explores the best use of a property or parcel of land. There are four criteria:

  • Legal Permissibility

    What uses are allowed by zoning, land-use rules, and other legal constraints?

  • Physical Possibility

    What can the site’s size, shape, terrain, and infrastructure support?

  • Financial Feasibility

    Can the proposed use generate enough value to justify its costs?

  • Maximum Productivity

    What is the highest output of value a parcel can provide given all constraints?

The tests run in order. Each one narrows the list of possible uses, and the use left standing after the fourth is the highest and best use.

Vacant or improved

Two views of the same site

Appraisers run the analysis twice: once as if the land were empty, and once as the property stands today with its existing buildings.

When the land would be worth more empty than the property is worth with its current building, the existing use is no longer the highest and best use. That gap is often the signal that a site is ready for redevelopment.

For investors

Why it matters to development investors

Highest and best use sets the ceiling on what a development project can be worth. Building a lower-value use than a site supports leaves value unrealized. Underwriting a use that fails the legal or physical test leads to delays, redesigns, or a project that never gets built.

That makes it one of the first questions to ask about any development deal: why is this the right use for this site, and what else was considered?

How HABU uses it

We use AI and technology to determine the highest and best use of properties exponentially faster and at massive scale. HABU is screening every parcel in the Phoenix MSA.

The same discipline drives the number development investors watch most closely. See yield on cost, explained.

Sources

Definition from The Appraisal of Real Estate (Appraisal Institute), as quoted in McKissock Learning, "Definition of Highest and Best Use." Four criteria as described by the International Right of Way Association, "Highest and Best Use," November/December 2021.